• In a repeated measures design, each individual participates
in each condition of the experiment.
• Why Researchers Use Repeated Measures Designs:
– researchers don’t have to worry
about balancing individual differences across conditions of the experiment because all participants are their own control.
– these designs require fewer participants,
– they are convenient and efficient,
and
– repeated measures designs are more
sensitive.
• A “sensitive” experiment is one that can
detect the effect of the independent variable, even when that effect is small.
• The main disadvantage of repeated measures designs
is practice effects.
• Practice effects arise because people change as they
are repeatedly tested.
– As participants complete the dependent
variable measures after each condition, they may get better with practice, or they may become tired or bored.
• Practice effects must be balanced, or averaged, across
the conditions of the experiment.
• Counterbalancing the order of the conditions makes
sure that the practice effects are distributed equally across the conditions of the experiment.
• Practice effects can’t be eliminated, but they
can be balanced, or averaged, across the conditions of an experiment.
• ABBA Counterbalancing
– Present the conditions of the experiment
in one sequence followed by the opposite of that sequence.
– ABBA counterbalancing balances practice
effects only when practice effects are “linear.”
– Linear practice effects occur when
participants change in the same way following each presentation of a condition.
– Nonlinear practice effects occur when
participants change dramatically following the administration of a condition.
• This can occur when participants experience an insight
regarding how to complete the experimental task during the course of the experiment.
• May happen through:
o Participants having a slow start with erratic or no pattern
to practice effects in beginning
o Participants having a sudden jump in practice effects
o Participants reaching a plateau in the pattern of practice
effects
Problem of Differential Transfer
• When should repeated measures designs not be recommended?
– When differential transfer is possible.
– This occurs when the effects of one
condition persist and affect participants’ experiences during subsequent conditions.
– Researchers can assess whether differential
transfer is a problem in their research by comparing the results for their independent variable when tested in a pilot study
using a random groups design and when tested in a repeated measures experiment.